February 3

Character Analysis Questions

Today in class, honors students listened (and followed along) to the classic fairy tale, Rumpelstiltskin. We did this to activate prior knowledge of the text (or learn the story for the first time) because our new read-aloud, Rump: The True Story of Rumpelstiltskin is a “fractured fairy tale.”

A broken fairy tale? you may be thinking. What in the world?  Here is a good definition if you’re unfamiliar with the genre: 

A re-working of a traditional fairy tale that retains familiar elements such as characters and plot, but alters the story in unexpected ways, often with a contemporary “spin” or ironic twist.

After reading the classic version, students were asked to create four character analysis questions. We have been learning about different types of response questions for our book club launch. Students are used to answering response questions but do not have as much practice creating them. And that is important for meaningful (and enjoyable) book club discussion.

Once students wrote their analysis questions in their reader’s notebooks, they were asked to leave their books open and go to another student’s notebook. They were asked to evaluate that students questions. Was it truly a character analysis question or did it ask about the setting? or a detail of the plot?
A character analysis question should ask the reader what he/she thinks about the character choices the author made when creating the character. Students should understand that authors use literary techniques to impact a reader. Furthermore, students should understand that authors use what a character says, does, and thinks (as well as other characters’ responses in the story TO that character) to create a believable character…one that is worthy of book club discussion.

Remember, when we analyze anything, we are breaking down that concept or idea into parts and showing the relationships among the parts.

Here are some Character Analysis question stems to get started:

  • Discuss the pros and cons of the character’s choice in this chapter.
  • How would you categorize the character? What peer group would this character “hang out with”?
  • How is this character similar to (insert another character’s name)?
  • How is this character connected to (the setting? the plot? the theme? another character?)?
  • How is this character different than another character?
  • What conclusions can you draw about this character based on his/her actions?
  • What could have caused this character to act this way?
  • What explanation do you have for the way the character does something?
  • What was the problem with the character?
  • What was the purpose of this main character? Or minor character?
  • Why do you think the author chose to (insert something the author decided to do ) with this character?

 

Here’s a glimpse at some student examples of this important skill:

20140203_140556 20140203_140603 (2) 20140203_140852 20140203_140906 20140203_141046 20140203_141102

February 2

Another way to connect with our class

instagram-logo

Many of you have shown interest in using Instagram for your independent reading project for Quarter 3. So I’ve created an account for myself (Follow me if you wish!):

OBrien_English

and I’ve created a hashtag for you to submit your photos related to classwork:

#OBrienAtERMS

I hope you enjoy this new way to communicate your learning with me and with one another! Remember to make sure you have the permission of your parents/guardians before posting or following. This is not a class requirement, just an optional, exciting new way to connect!

January 28

Reflection on Quarter 2 Reading

set goalsbookshelf collage

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

It’s the end of another quarter and you know what that means! It’s time to reflect on all of the wonderful reading we did this nine weeks! With lots of snow days, I can’t wait to see how many awesome titles you devoured! 

 

1. What was your quarter 2 reading goal? Did you meet it?

2. Why or why not? 

3. What genre did you read a lot of this quarter? Did you try any new genres? What genres have you still not tried (consider reading one from a different genre this quarter)?

4.  How many pages did you read for quarter 2?

5. Compare your page total in #4 to the total number of pages you read for quarter 1. What do you notice?

6. What was your favorite book for quarter 2? Why did you like it?

7. What book did you dislike or not like as much as others? Why do you think that is?

8. What would you like your quarter 3 goal to be? (Challenge yourself but make it attainable, too). 

 

December 4

HOMEWORK: Consider your Audience – Find a Unique Focus

Students, as we continue our research process, I want you to take time now to consider your potential audience. Imagine your readers–that is, whoever you picture reading your research article when you’re done. In the comment section, your assignment tonight is to write a brief entry considering what you assume your readers do not already know and what you have to research  to support their learning of your topic.

If you are researching your topic only because it is an assignment, your engagement with the process and your learning will only be a fraction of what it could be. It’s important to consider your audience when writing, but also as you collect your sources, too, in the prewriting stage.

Students usually tell me that they are writing their assignment “for the class.” While the class is a perfectly good audience, I want you to learn that you can write pieces for specific individuals in the class (friends or classmates with similar interests) or outside the class (relatives or community leaders) and also for a more general audience (readers of the school). People usually start writing something because they have a real audience in mind, and if you want to be a truly independent writer, then you need to do the same.

So an important place to start is to ask yourself, “What do I think people who might learn from my research not already know?” and then, “What will I have to find out so I can be sure they learn about those parts of this topic?” Watch how I try this with the topic I am studying, the importance of sleep.

Let me first think before I write…

I think people that learn from my research may not already know…well, I actually think more people know that sleep is important to humans and we need to get a certain amount each night to feel good. So I guess I don’t need to spend too much time studying those obvious facts…But they probably won’t know how many hours each night they need to sleep to be feeling their best the next day upon waking. I think my students who read this will wonder how many hours a night middle-schoolers should get to learn the best (and probably parents, too)…and adults reading my article will be interested in the amount of sleep recommended for adults. I may even need to compare the amount of sleep humans need as they grow and develop and reach different ages. It will probably also be helpful for me to include information on ways to make sure you’re getting the best possible sleep. Are there certain important guidelines to follow to make sure we’re getting the best sleep? Also, what should a person do if they’re having trouble sleeping? And even though I think my readers will know that getting a good night’s sleep is important, I don’t think they will know all the ways it impacts us during the waking hours. In high school and college I would stay up REALLY late studying and reading and I would feel very tired the next day…but it became a hard habit to break. How much did losing all that sleep really affect my life? Would I have been wiser to go to bed earlier and get up earlier? I always just assumed I was a natural “night-person” and not a “morning person” like many of my friends and family members. Maybe I should include in my audience anyone who may also be a “night-person” who is curious if they can convert to being a morning person. Or is it predetermined genetically? 

Do you see what I’m doing? I’m taking a moment, very early on in collecting sources and starting to read, to think about my audience and what they might need to know. It is helping me focus or narrow my research, so I spend time learning those things that I think readers will most need to learn.

Here is another example from a student:

After you read it, go ahead and write your own by commenting on this post. See you tomorrow!

Student Example

Student Example

December 3

Post your 5-7 Research Questions HERE!

In writing workshop we wrote five-seven questions that we wanted to know about our topic for our magazine article. We will write our questions here to share them with our classmates and teacher. In class we talked about What makes a good question?

At the library we looked for and checked out at least one nonfiction book to use for our magazine article. We will read this book and look for questions. We will use all we know about reading nonfiction. In class, we will be learning a new nonfiction strategy called, “2-Column Notes” to add to our non fiction strategies. 

What 5-7 Questions do you Hope to Learn About your Topic?

What 5-7 Questions do you Hope to Learn About your Topic?

 

November 28

Block 1/5 is reading…

1.5

Left to Right – Ava, Amanda, Latiksha

Ava – Matched by Ally Condie

“I just started it but I like it because they don’t make the beginning drag on like some books. This book jumps right to the point of the story which is being matched with the person that you’re going to stay with forever. I haven’t found out yet who Cassia is going to be matched with so I’m looking forward to reading on to find out! Once you get “matched” with your person, you get a microchip with that person’s history on it so you can learn about them because they’re from another country. The back of the story talks about a rebellion so my prediction is that Cassia is going to rebel against the person her society has matched her with. I would recommend this to someone who likes a love story but at the same time, likes reading about rebellion and fighting, too.”

Amanda – Insurgent by Veronica Roth

“I’m almost halfway through it. It’s a really good book. I would say it’s even better than the first book, Divergent. I can’t say too much about it because it would give too much away. But I can say that Divergent is about the human race being divided into different factions by the way they behave (tell the truth, if they’re violent, selfless, etc.). The main character is Tris and she’s mainly Abnegation which means she’s selfless and they’re all about other people…they can’t look in the mirror or speak about themselves. She takes an aptitude test to find out which faction she should go to. She faces a decision about where she should go…read more to find out!
My favorite book was The Gollywhopper Games until I read this. I would give it 12 out of 10 stars!”
NOTE: The movie for Divergent is coming out in March, 2014! 

Latiksha – The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho
“I’m almost done with it. I only have 6 pages left. It’s a REALLY good book. It’s really adventurous so if you like action then this is the book for you. So it’s about a boy who’s 12 years old. He’s trying to find the pyramids so he can find his personal legend. Along the way he finds the alchemist and he tells the boy his personal legend. While the young boy is in the Sahara he finds his love, Fatima. My favorite part is when he reaches the oasis and he’s living in a tent. A first-grade teacher from Cedar Lane recommended it to me this year.”